Shop multiple homeowners insurance carriers in one place providing service and consultation from a licensed Cayuga County, NY agent.

Cayuga County, NY Homeowners Insurance Quotes

Are you looking for a quick comparison of Cayuga County, NY homeowners insurance quotes to review and compare the best rates today? We can provide up to 12 or more competitive home insurance rates with different coverage options from a basic HO-3 standard homeowner policy to a bundle / packaged discount policy that would include your home and auto grouped together. A basic policy for homeowners living in Cayuga County includes protection against most major perils. If you are in need of earthquake or flood insurance, then we can help you find additional coverage. As you may know, a flood policy is separate from a standard HO-3 policy.

Coastal Cayuga County, NY Home Insurance

Cayuga County is located near the coast as you know, so it is important to understand that flood protection is crucial for homes in your area that are prone to hurricanes and tropical wind storms. We recommend you speak with us if you have questions about your coastal homeowners insurance coverage. Flood insurance is not part of your basic homeowners (HO-3) policy, but can easily be bundled to help give you the added protection you need. We offer an easy way to review the best flood insurance rates for Cayuga County, please give us a call at 888-620-1954 for completitive flood insurance rates in your area.

Affordable Cayuga County Rates

Homeowners living in Cayuga County, pay on average around $1356 per year or $113.00 a month for home insurance. Let us help you shop multiple coverage options and provide up to 40% off in discount savings for your home in Cayuga County. Online rate quotes can be easily reviewed by entering your zip code of the property you would like to insure or give us a call now at 1-855-976-2656

For all Cayuga County, NY residents, you can select your city below to review more information about homeowners insurance in your local area. Information includes city demographics, facts and average premium rates for homeowners on an annual and montly basis. If you are searching for insurance rates nearby then click your city below.


Are you looking for a homeowners insurance quote in Cayuga County? Simply enter your zip code to get your New York homeowners insurance quotes and receive up to 12 competitive quotes and coverage options in your area.

Cayuga County, NY Housing Demographics

With 80,026 residents living within the Cayuga County area there are over 36,489 homeowners looking for more affordable home insurance rates. Your homeowners policy is written to help protect your home and family. With an estimated 20,264 families living within the local area, it is safe to say that great coverage at an affordable price is most desired amongst every homeowner living in Cayuga County.

DemographicValues
Total Occupied Households31,445
Family Households (families)20,264
Average Owner Occupied Household Size3
Average Family Size3
Total Housing Units36,489

Cayuga County, NY Coastal Wind, Hail & Flood Information

For all homeowners living in Cayuga County (FIPS: 36011), it's important to understand that this county is in a coastal area and has great risk of damage due to hurricanes, windstorms, hail and flooding. The wind and hail insurance program provided through the state of New York is the states opportunity to help provide additional wind/hail coverage when insurance companies exclude it from homeowners and other policies sold to coastal residents. You can buy wind and hail insurance coverage through us and we will shop multiple companies to package the best coverage option for you. If you are shopping for quotes in Cayuga County, NY, it's important that you look into hurricane and windstorm insurance options.

Cayuga County boarders a shoreline which increases the risk of wind, hail and flood damage. We will look into providing the best rates possible considering your home is located in the coastal area of New York.

Helpful Articles:

Cayuga County, NY Home Insurance Average Premiums

Local Cayuga, NY homeowners insurance quotes comparison

$1,131 /yr.

New York's Average Home Insurance Rates Overall

For the state of New York, homeowners insurance premiums have changed based on a variety of different factors related to risk and is currently ranked 16 in the nation for highest premiums in the U.S.

Average RatingAnnual Premium
Minimum Range:$842 /yr.
Current Average Cost:$1,131 /yr.
Maximum Range:$1357 /yr.

Cayuga County, NY Coastal Wind, Hail & Flood Information

Cayuga is a coastal county which greatly increases the risk of hurricanes and windstorms. Our quoting process will include wind and hail coverage options to give you the best protection you need against high winds and storm damage.

Flood Zone Notice: The beautiful coastal county of Cayuga is know for it's beautiful beaches and waterways. Because Cayuga County (FIPS: 36011) has a shoreline and is in a coastal area it is important to purchase flood insurance. The risk is very high in this area and we will work with you to provide the best flood insurance coverage you need for your home in Cayuga County.

New York Homeowners Insurance News & Information

  • Homeowners Now Use This Strategy To Save Money on Home Insurance. Is It a Good Idea? Posted on Wednesday 26th March, 2025

    According to a new Market Watch article, homeowners who are struggling with the cost of higher homeowner insurance premiums are making the move to policies with higher deductibles to help lower their costs. While this strategy may work for some, it is not the best idea for everyone.  Data from the Intercontinental Exchange (ICE) showed […]

  • Florida Homeowners With Insurance Are Struggling to Get Claims Paid – Why? Posted on Wednesday 19th March, 2025

    According to a recent Moneywise article, homeowners with insurance coverage in Florida are struggling to get claims paid.  Chad Zalva, a single dad in Riverview, Florida, was cited as an example in the article as a homeowner who is carrying homeowners insurance but was recently surprised to learn that the damage to his home from […]

  • 2025 List of States Where Finding Home Insurance Is Most Difficult and Why Posted on Tuesday 11th March, 2025

    Homeowners insurance is a necessity if you own a home, particularly if you are currently carrying a mortgage. Mortgage lenders require homeowners insurance to protect their investment in your home by always carrying homeowners insurance.  If your insurance is cancelled or you are non-renewed it can be a huge problem. As wildfires and major windstorms […]

  • Will Citizens Policyholders See a Home Insurance Rate Decrease?  Posted on Tuesday 11th March, 2025

    Recently, Gov. Ron DeSantis announced that over 20% of Citizens property insurance policyholders will see a premium decrease of roughly 5.6%. DeSantis also claimed that almost 73% of homeowners who have a policy with Citizens in Miami-Dade County will see a rate reduction of 6.3% on average. The state-run insurer, Citizens Property is finally shedding […]

  • Can $600 Million Help Lower Florida Homeowners Insurance Rates? Posted on Friday 14th February, 2025

    Family relax on the couch. Happy beautiful young parents are smiling, hugging and playing with them kids at home together Governor DeSantis recently asked the legislature for over $600 million to help lower homeowners insurance in his 2025-26 budget request. The budget proposal asks for $590 million to go towards the My Safe Florida Home […]

Discounts For Homeowners in Cayuga County

As a homeowner, you have to understand that insurance companies see homes as a risk. If you can decrease any of the risk factors that will determine your premium, then it's best to follow these important guidelines in order to save money on your New York homeowners insurance.

  • Install A Smoke Alarm in Every Room: It's important you do this for your own safety, so why not install a smoke detector in every room. Show your home insurance company that safety comes first. Once you have them installed, shop for home insurance and mentioned you have taken the right safety precautions to reduce house fires. For homeowners in Cayuga County, this discount can save you up to 20% on your home insurance premium.
  • Combine Your Home and Auto Insurance Into One Package: Any home insurance provider is going to want your business. It's important you offer this opportunity to combine your home and auto insurance together in one package. You may want to also see if you can open up a life or health insurance account as well. Merging all your insurance into one company will save you money. Homeowners in Cayuga County that do combine their home and auto can save over $500 with this discount.
  • Install A Home Security System: Your home insurance company should reward you for installing a home security system, sometimes up to 22%. It's important that you take precautions and reduce the risk of someone breaking into your Cayuga County home. This will be one of the questions that you will want to ask your home insurance agent to see if you qualify for this discount. If you don't, make sure you shop other companies to get the "Home Security Discount"
  • Purchase A Fire Exstinguisher: Although smoke alarms provide warnings, it's best to be prepared. This may or may not provide any stand alone discount, but it shows your serious when it comes to reducing risk.
  • Stop Smoking: It's important to protect your health and your home. If you don't smoke or don't have anyone living with you that smokes then this can save you up to 18% on your home insurance premium.

Cayuga County Housing & Real Estate Data

Details:Statistics
Total Housing Units36489
Occupied Housing Units31445
Vacant Housing Units5044
Vacant Housing Units for Rent670
Vacant Housing Units Rented Not Occupied54
Vacant Housing Units For Sale357
Vacant Housing Units Sold Not Occupied131
Vacant Housing Units For Seasonal Occasional Use2885
Vacant Housing Units All Other Vacants947
Housing Units Homeowner Vacancy Rate Percent2
Housing Units Rental Vacancy Rate Percent7
Housing Tenure Occupied Units31445
Housing Tenure Occupied Units Owner Occupied22367
Housing Tenure Occupied Units Owner Occupied Population56499
Housing Tenure Occupied Units Owner Occupied Averge Household Size3
Housing Tenure Occupied Units Renter Occupied9078
Housing Tenure Occupied Units Renter Occupied Population19282
Housing Tenure Occupied Units Renter Occupied Average Household Size2